Singleton Shmingleton - Recommission
Jesse Barker PlotkinJanuary 13, 2025
Recommission some Unearth-like spells in new ways for maximum value!
| art by Jehan Choo
Fun-Sized s
Hello, and welcome back to Singleton Shmingleton, where I bend the singleton rules of Commander by building decks with as many functional reprints of a certain card as possible.
On the docket today is a card that has been a perennially solid Limited pick for the last few years, while also breaking into Standard in fringe decks.
is an exciting rate: for two mana, we can return a three drop to the battlefield and even give it a bonus counter. In terms of raw stats, that's incredible; but it does have a real setup cost.
Last winter, we got an even more efficient version of this effect in , and those two cards enabled a spicy Standard deck alongside and that tried to play a pure tempo game and never let the opponent regain balance.
But before and , there was . Dating all the way back to Urza's Legacy, this card has been the paragon of efficiency of "fair" spells, seeing niche play in several formats. And for a long time, it was fairly unique.
White got several cards that cared about returning permanents with cost two or less, from to , but and ushered in the era of returning three drops, and this effect has proliferated in both white and black.
There are now fifteen ways to return a three drop from the graveyard to the battlefield for three or fewer mana. Here they are:
The most played of these cards, in 162,007 decks, is . This spell is not only a huge amount of flexibility and value from your hand and from the graveyard, it also forms part of any pile in cEDH alongside , making it a staple there.
The next most played card is itself, seeing play in 84,757 decks. It's still an incredible value card, cheap in terms of mana and money, and carries the name recognition of twenty-five years of cool plays. The least played card on this list, by a long shot, is .
Most of these cards see decent play, in a few thousand decks, but this one is only in 115 decks. It is a common from a Jumpstart set, so many people (myself included) have probably never seen it before, and it can never actually discount a three drop.
At the Three-Point Line
These cards give us an efficient way to put cheap creatures into play, but we want to focus on three drops in specific. Just like in basketball, three is more than two, so we should never take a layup (I totally know how basketball works).
If we can fill our graveyard well enough, then our 'yard can act as a sort of toolbox for our s to pull from.
So what kind of three-pointers do we want to include? One for every situation, and the best in the game.
First off, we'll want ways to interact. and can act as removal for creatures, can deal with artifacts and enchantments, and can even stop instants and sorceries before they happen.
's Echo ability may not be pure downside in this deck; having an easy way to return it to the graveyard makes it re-usable!
Any Commander deck needs to pack some ramp and card draw, and this deck is no exception. can catch us up by two whole lands if someone else is going fast, and can make sure we hit our land drops while filling our graveyard further.
For card draw, all of , , and can refill our hand as we continue to run out little utility creatures.
And if we're talking three pointers, there are some veritable Steph Curries that we can't leave on the bench (surely that analogy tracks). forms the backbone of any toolbox strategy, letting us find the perfect answer to any situation.
broke Legacy and still holds its own in Vintage, and while the Initiative isn't always as insurmountable in multiplayer as in one-on-one, when it is, it's the best thing we can be doing, and so deserves a spot in our toolbox.
And since most of our creatures gain value through enters triggers, can double up any of our little guy's' effects. There are a couple more cards that aren't of quite the same caliber, but pull their weight in this deck in particular.
and both pay us off for bringing them out of the graveyard rather than from our hand, and even in Commander they're impressive beaters.
A Tempting Twist
While I was looking at all of the wonderful three drops we could play, I stumbled across another card that fits this strategy incredibly well. wants us to get as many copies as possible into play, and if we can stock our graveyard well enough, our s can effectively give us extra copies by making us see a lot of them more often.
The first results in one counter on itself, but the second leads to two on both, and the third leads to three counters on each of three . Exponential growth is nothing to scoff at, so we want to see as many of these Wraiths as we can in order to speed-run the emblem, and grow our army of into a formidable board.
There are a surprising number of ways that fit into the strategy that we've already outlined. Even though they grow, they enter as one-powered creatures, meaning they still synergize with and our -style effects.
We have a ton of small creatures that benefit from becoming ring-bearers, as Skulk is best on small creatures. And the second level of works quite well with our strategy of filling our graveyard and seeing as many cards as possible.
There is one card we just need to run alongside in this deck: . All of our are knights, so lets us cast them from our graveyard and hold up our s for other creatures.
Plus, his downside of not being castable except from the graveyard is hardly an obstacle, since we're looking to stock our graveyard, and can even just discard him to a trigger.
doesn't show up anywhere on 's High Synergy page, and I think people are sleeping on this interaction.
Stocking the Graveyard
The limiting factor on our strategy is our ability to dump our deck into the graveyard so we can pick and choose whatever we need from it. Luckily, in black we've got a ton of powerful options to mill large chunks of cards at a time.
Starting off with three black enchantments, , , and all offer tons of mill while also giving advantage.
and give us the chance to get extra cards, and turns into a powerful endgame engine if it lasts long enough.
Dredge is always a powerful way to fill up a graveyard, but in this deck, and are all-stars. If we get to the second level of , then we can Dredge back a creature when our Ring-bearer attacks, and then discard it again, letting us re-use the effect over and over.
Plus, is a respectable target for s as a Flying blocker that can kill any size of attacker. And we couldn't make a package of creatures that mill without including , the most efficient one of all.
The Decklist
Unearthly Delights
This is one of the most consistent decks I've played. With nine copies of and fourteen s, it's going to do its thing every single game. But what surprised me is that, despite the reliability of the core engine, the games play out differently every time.
The rest of our deck is a toolbox of reactive creatures, and so we can pivot easily from offense to defense, and the pace of our game depends on what our opponents are up to.
If you're a fan of the scrappy gameplay of Death and Taxes decks in Modern and Legacy, this deck plays out a lot like that, trying to disrupt our opponents just enough to stop them from outpacing our army.
Until Next Time
The game's very first win condition remains one of the most returned-to designs of all time. There are dozens of riffs on this card, and many have served to cap off big mana combos throughout the game's history.
Commander is the format with the biggest mana of all, so what shenanigans can we get up to with this most fundamental of all wizarding spells?
Read More
Sméagol, Helpful Guide Commander Deck Tech Conditions Allow - Frodo, Sauron's Bane EDH