Withar, Cocoon Keeper (Commander) - Expensive Self-Damage

Original Name:

Mister NegativeMister Negative

Withar, Cocoon Keeper
Rank #471
25decks
As CommanderAs CardAverage DeckDecks
Bracket
All
1
234
5
Budget
Any$$$$
Andy Zupke
Dec 11, 2025
Andy Zupke
The EDHREC Writers' Favorite New Commanders of 2025
The writing staff at EDHREC gives you the rundown on their favorite new commanders that came out in 2025. Is your favorite on the list?
Deck Filters
Cardsphere
Archidekt
Commander Spellbook
Moxfield
Scryfall
MTGStocks
New Cards
Top Cards
High Lift Cards
Creatures
Instants
Sorceries
Utility Artifacts
Enchantments
Utility Lands
Mana Artifacts
Lands
Back to Top
Flickering Hound
50%inclusion1 decks2 decks
13xlift
Gleaming Splendor
10%inclusion1 decks10 decks
0.3xlift
Darksteel Angel
9.1%inclusion1 decks11 decks
4.9xlift
The Queen of Dale
9.1%inclusion1 decks11 decks
0.5xlift
Bilbo's Gambit
9.1%inclusion1 decks11 decks
1.0xlift
Top Cards
Vito, Thorn of the Dusk Rose
92%inclusion23 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Swords to Plowshares
84%inclusion21 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Necropotence
80%inclusion20 decks25 decks
1.5xlift
Ephemerate
80%inclusion20 decks25 decks
4.1xlift
Enduring Tenacity
80%inclusion20 decks25 decks
1.7xlift
Black Market Connections
80%inclusion20 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Bloodletter of Aclazotz
76%inclusion19 decks25 decks
2.4xlift
Lotho, Corrupt Shirriff
76%inclusion19 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Dark Ritual
72%inclusion18 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Children of Korlis
64%inclusion16 decks25 decks
1.6xlift
High Lift Cards
Avatar's Wrath
25%inclusion5 decks20 decks
5.5xlift
Cloudshift
60%inclusion15 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Gideon of the Trials
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Teleportation Circle
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Restoration Angel
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Parting Gust
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Conjurer's Closet
44%inclusion11 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Plague Drone
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Tree of Perdition
44%inclusion11 decks25 decks
4.3xlift
Psychosis Crawler
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
4.2xlift
Creatures
Wall of Blood
60%inclusion15 decks25 decks
3.2xlift
Sheoldred, the Apocalypse
56%inclusion14 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Esper Sentinel
52%inclusion13 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
K'rrik, Son of Yawgmoth
44%inclusion11 decks25 decks
1.7xlift
Dark Confidant
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Blood Celebrant
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
3.3xlift
Grand Abolisher
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Witch Enchanter
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Gray Merchant of Asphodel
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
1.7xlift
Doom Whisperer
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
3.8xlift
Voice of Victory
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Gwenom, Remorseless
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
2.5xlift
Platinum Angel
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
2.5xlift
Bloodthirsty Conqueror
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
0.7xlift
Astarion, the Decadent
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
2.7xlift
Crypt Ghast
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
1.5xlift
Vizkopa Guildmage
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
1.6xlift
Soul's Attendant
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Kambal, Consul of Allocation
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
0.7xlift
Vilis, Broker of Blood
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Loran of the Third Path
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
2.2xlift
Soul Warden
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
0.7xlift
Archivist of Oghma
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
0.7xlift
Serra Ascendant
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Auriok Champion
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.8xlift
Charming Prince
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
3.3xlift
Orcish Bowmasters
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Tataru Taru
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
M.O.D.O.K.
18%inclusion2 decks11 decks
2.8xlift
Solemn Simulacrum
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
2.7xlift
Darkstar Augur
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
0.7xlift
Elesh Norn, Mother of Machines
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
2.1xlift
Boggart Trawler
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Sorin of House Markov
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Keen Duelist
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
1.9xlift
Magus of the Mirror
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
3.1xlift
Creeping Bloodsucker
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Weathered Wayfarer
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.6xlift
Herald of Eternal Dawn
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Phelia, Exuberant Shepherd
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Unstoppable Slasher
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
3.5xlift
Defiant Bloodlord
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Enduring Angel
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
2.8xlift
Flickerwisp
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Mischievous Poltergeist
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Suture Priest
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
0.6xlift
Deep Gnome Terramancer
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
2.0xlift
Deepwood Ghoul
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Academy Rector
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
3.5xlift
Bitterbloom Bearer
9.1%inclusion2 decks22 decks
1.1xlift
Instants
Angel's Grace
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
1.6xlift
Malakir Rebirth
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
1.8xlift
Anguished Unmaking
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Vampiric Tutor
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Teferi's Protection
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Snuff Out
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
2.5xlift
Enlightened Tutor
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
0.7xlift
Cabal Ritual
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Ad Nauseam
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Flicker of Fate
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
3.7xlift
Silence
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Inkshield
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Stunning Reversal
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
2.6xlift
Path to Exile
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
0.5xlift
Reprieve
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
1.7xlift
Deadly Rollick
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
0.5xlift
Fell the Profane
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
0.7xlift
Flare of Fortitude
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.5xlift
Rebuff the Wicked
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
2.9xlift
False Cure
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
2.9xlift
Orim's Chant
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Saw in Half
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
1.7xlift
Generous Gift
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Eerie Interlude
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Stinging Study
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Imp's Mischief
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Culling the Weak
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
0.5xlift
Necrologia
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
3.5xlift
Stroke of Midnight
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Personify
12%inclusion2 decks17 decks
5.5xlift
Justiciar's Portal
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Plunge into Darkness
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Dire Tactics
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
3.1xlift
Everybody Lives!
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Hatred
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Getaway Glamer
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Slip On the Ring
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Disenchant
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Despark
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.6xlift
Heliod's Intervention
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.5xlift
Fracture
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Withering Torment
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
3.1xlift
Airbender's Reversal
5.0%inclusion1 decks20 decks
5.4xlift
Sorceries
Toxic Deluge
64%inclusion16 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Demonic Tutor
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Damn
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Night's Whisper
44%inclusion11 decks25 decks
1.5xlift
Reanimate
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Sign in Blood
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
1.7xlift
Exsanguinate
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Decorum Dissertation
29%inclusion4 decks14 decks
2.9xlift
Imperial Seal
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Feed the Swarm
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
1.7xlift
Agadeem's Awakening
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Repay in Kind
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Reverse the Sands
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
2.1xlift
Beseech the Mirror
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Sevinne's Reclamation
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Peer into the Abyss
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
1.7xlift
Profane Transfusion
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Pain's Reward
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
3.1xlift
Farewell
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Grim Tutor
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
0.7xlift
Fix What's Broken
14%inclusion2 decks14 decks
5.7xlift
Vanquish the Horde
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
2.0xlift
Oketra's Last Mercy
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.6xlift
Damnation
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Diabolic Intent
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.4xlift
Ondu Inversion
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
3.1xlift
Flicker
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Profane Tutor
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Yawgmoth's Will
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Terminus
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Infernal Contract
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.9xlift
Read the Bones
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Blasphemous Edict
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Scheming Symmetry
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Sickening Dreams
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Insatiable Avarice
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Dark Deal
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Daydream
7.1%inclusion1 decks14 decks
5.9xlift
Utility Artifacts
Bolas's Citadel
60%inclusion15 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
The One Ring
56%inclusion14 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Jet Medallion
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
2.6xlift
Tainted Sigil
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Soul Conduit
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
2.6xlift
Aetherflux Reservoir
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
0.6xlift
Pact Weapon
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.7xlift
Archaeomancer's Map
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
The Wind Crystal
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Sensei's Divining Top
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
0.6xlift
Spellbook
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Mirror Universe
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
2.8xlift
The Golden Throne
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
The Endstone
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.6xlift
Pearl Medallion
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Ashnod's Altar
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.6xlift
Panharmonicon
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Wishclaw Talisman
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.4xlift
Expedition Map
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.6xlift
Lich's Mirror
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
3.1xlift
Enchantments
Sanguine Bond
64%inclusion16 decks25 decks
1.7xlift
Smothering Tithe
52%inclusion13 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Tainted Remedy
52%inclusion13 decks25 decks
4.1xlift
Phyrexian Unlife
52%inclusion13 decks25 decks
2.8xlift
Exquisite Blood
52%inclusion13 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Authority of the Consuls
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Necrodominance
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
2.7xlift
Axis of Mortality
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
1.9xlift
Blind Obedience
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Unspeakable Symbol
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
1.9xlift
Wound Reflection
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
4.0xlift
Ghostly Prison
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
2.2xlift
Phyrexian Arena
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Touch the Spirit Realm
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Lich's Mastery
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
3.3xlift
Animate Dead
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Parker Luck
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
3.3xlift
Land Tax
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Airbender Ascension
15%inclusion3 decks20 decks
5.5xlift
Lich
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Phyrexian Reclamation
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Underworld Dreams
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Triskaidekaphobia
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
3.5xlift
Trouble in Pairs
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Quantum Entanglement
9.1%inclusion1 decks11 decks
5.5xlift
Darksteel Mutation
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.9xlift
Rest in Peace
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
3.1xlift
The Meathook Massacre
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.4xlift
Dance of the Dead
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Greed
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Bitterblossom
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.6xlift
The Legend of Yangchen
5.0%inclusion1 decks20 decks
5.5xlift
Utility Lands
Reliquary Tower
80%inclusion20 decks25 decks
2.5xlift
Ancient Tomb
72%inclusion18 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Urborg, Tomb of Yawgmoth
72%inclusion18 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Bojuka Bog
56%inclusion14 decks25 decks
1.5xlift
Cabal Coffers
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Urza's Saga
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Takenuma, Abandoned Mire
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Hall of Heliod's Generosity
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
1.6xlift
Multiversal Passage
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
4.1xlift
Phyrexian Tower
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Command Beacon
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
3.1xlift
Shizo, Death's Storehouse
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Nykthos, Shrine to Nyx
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.5xlift
Crystal Vein
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
2.8xlift
Boseiju, Who Shelters All
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
War Room
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.4xlift
Emergence Zone
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.5xlift
Eiganjo, Seat of the Empire
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.5xlift
Leechridden Swamp
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Vault of the Archangel
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.3xlift
City of Traitors
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Rogue's Passage
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.7xlift
Ishgard, the Holy See
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Mana Artifacts
Sol Ring
100%inclusion25 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Arcane Signet
96%inclusion24 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Talisman of Hierarchy
80%inclusion20 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Thought Vessel
68%inclusion17 decks25 decks
2.7xlift
The Soul Stone
60%inclusion15 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Chrome Mox
52%inclusion13 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Mana Vault
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Fellwar Stone
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Mox Diamond
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
1.6xlift
The Mind Stone
36%inclusion5 decks14 decks
2.3xlift
Orzhov Signet
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
0.7xlift
Lotus Petal
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Mox Opal
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Grim Monolith
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Thran Dynamo
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
2.3xlift
Decanter of Endless Water
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
3.5xlift
Phial of Galadriel
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
4.7xlift
Staff of Compleation
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Mox Amber
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.3xlift
Springleaf Drum
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.6xlift
Lands
Command Tower
96%inclusion24 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Swamp
92%inclusion23 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Godless Shrine
92%inclusion23 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Plains
92%inclusion23 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Marsh Flats
92%inclusion23 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Vault of Champions
92%inclusion23 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Caves of Koilos
84%inclusion21 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Scrubland
76%inclusion19 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Isolated Chapel
68%inclusion17 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Silent Clearing
64%inclusion16 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Shadowy Backstreet
60%inclusion15 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Windswept Heath
56%inclusion14 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Bleachbone Verge
56%inclusion14 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Arid Mesa
56%inclusion14 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Polluted Delta
56%inclusion14 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Bloodstained Mire
56%inclusion14 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Shattered Sanctum
52%inclusion13 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Mana Confluence
52%inclusion13 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Malakir Rebirth
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
1.8xlift
Flooded Strand
48%inclusion12 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Verdant Catacombs
44%inclusion11 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Brightclimb Pathway
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Fetid Heath
40%inclusion10 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Witch Enchanter
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
1.1xlift
Exotic Orchard
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
2.8xlift
City of Brass
36%inclusion9 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Prismatic Vista
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
1.0xlift
Cavern of Souls
32%inclusion8 decks25 decks
1.5xlift
Tainted Field
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Orzhov Basilica
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Gemstone Caverns
28%inclusion7 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Agadeem's Awakening
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
1.2xlift
Starting Town
24%inclusion6 decks25 decks
1.8xlift
Turbulent Moor
21%inclusion3 decks14 decks
0.9xlift
Fell the Profane
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
0.7xlift
Concealed Courtyard
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Shineshadow Snarl
20%inclusion5 decks25 decks
1.3xlift
Horizon of Progress
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
2.7xlift
Tarnished Citadel
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
3.1xlift
Boggart Trawler
16%inclusion4 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Fabled Passage
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Desolate Mire
12%inclusion3 decks25 decks
1.4xlift
Ondu Inversion
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
3.1xlift
Myriad Landscape
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
1.6xlift
Reflecting Pool
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.8xlift
Snow-Covered Plains
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.6xlift
Snow-Covered Swamp
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.6xlift
Temple of Silence
8.0%inclusion2 decks25 decks
0.9xlift
Eclipsed Steppe
7.1%inclusion1 decks14 decks
0.7xlift
About UsContactPrivacy PolicyTerms of Service
Space Cow MediaArchidektCardsphereCommander SpellbookFABRECSpellvoid
Space Cow MediaArchidektCommander's Herald
Commander SpellbookFABRECSpellvoid
EDHREC is unofficial Fan Content permitted under the Fan Content Policy. Not approved/endorsed by Wizards. Portions of the materials used are property of Wizards of the Coast. ©Wizards of the Coast LLC.
next@15 test